Skip main navigation

Caitlin Shelton

Realty Connect USA
Contact Caitlin

Recent Sales

Skip to the end of the carousel
  • $605,000
    4 bd2 ba1,416 sqft Islip, NY
    4 bd2 ba1,416 sqft
    Islip, NY
    Sold 3 months ago
    Seller
    41 Oak Street, Islip, NY, 11751
  • $771,000
    4 bd2 ba2,000 sqft East Northport, NY
    4 bd2 ba2,000 sqft
    East Northport, NY
    Sold 7 months ago
    Seller
    634 6th Avenue W, East Northport, NY, 11731
  • $625,000
    3 bd3 ba1,800 sqft West Babylon, NY
    3 bd3 ba1,800 sqft
    West Babylon, NY
    Sold 1 year ago
    Seller
    32 Maple Street, West Babylon, NY, 11704
  • $635,000
    4 bd2 ba1,800 sqft East Islip, NY
    4 bd2 ba1,800 sqft
    East Islip, NY
    Sold 1 year ago
    Seller
    110 Schoolhouse Road, East Islip, NY, 11730
  • $785,000
    4 bd3 ba3,212 sqft Sayville, NY
    4 bd3 ba3,212 sqft
    Sayville, NY
    Sold 1 year ago
    BuyerSeller
    250 Johnson Avenue, Sayville, NY, 11782
Skip to the beginning of the carousel
2
Sales last 12 months
58
Total sales
$525K-$785K
Price range
$641K
Average price

Get to know Caitlin Shelton

Real Estate Salesperson

Specialties
Buyer's AgentListing AgentRelocationMovingProperty ManagementRentals
20 Years of experience

Caitlin Shelton's listings & sales (58)

For Sale
For Rent
Sold
This map can show the most recent 100 listings and 100 sales. Review all listings and sales below.

For Sale

Active listings data currently unavailable.

Sold (58)

Address
Sold date
Closing price
Represented
Flag Sale
9/16/2025$605,000Seller
5/15/2025$771,000Seller
11/8/2024$625,000Seller
10/17/2024$635,000Seller
9/4/2024$785,000Buyer and Seller

Caitlin Shelton's reviews (18)

Skip to the end of the carousel
  • 5.0
    • 9/23/2025
    • BiggyHolewinski

    Sold a home in 2025.

    So happy I had Caitlin as my realtor. Very efficient and positive attitude. Within 2 weeks I had a buyer for my house, without even putting up a “for sale” sign. Would de...
    So happy I had Caitlin as my realtor. Very efficient and positive attitude. Within 2 weeks I had a buyer for my house, without eve...
    5.0
    • 10/11/2024
    • zuser20150307155039693

    Bought and sold a home in 2024.

    Caitlin helped me to sell my house and start a new journey in a new house. What really stood out to me was her communication. She was always quick to respond and kept me...
    Caitlin helped me to sell my house and start a new journey in a new house. What really stood out to me was her communication. She...
  • 5.0
    • 10/11/2024
    • zuser20140824063142182

    Bought and sold a Single Family home in 2024 in Sayville, NY.

    Caitlin was on top of everything, ensuring our property was represented to its full potential and getting us the dream home we have always wanted. She’s a team player and...
    Caitlin was on top of everything, ensuring our property was represented to its full potential and getting us the dream home we hav...
    5.0
    • 9/5/2023
    • nrodriguezx127

    Bought a Single Family home in 2023 in East islip, NY.

    My husband and I have been back and forth with wanting to find a home for about 3 years and Caitlyn has been nothing but patient with us. She was very knowledgeable and a...
    My husband and I have been back and forth with wanting to find a home for about 3 years and Caitlyn has been nothing but patient w...
  • 5.0
    • 11/23/2022
    • Susan Comerford

    Bought a Condo home in 2020 in Medford, NY.

    Caitlin Shelton assisted me in finding a great home that fits my needs entirely. She was knowledgeable about different areas that would suit me and never tired of our sea...
    Caitlin Shelton assisted me in finding a great home that fits my needs entirely. She was knowledgeable about different areas that ...
    5.0
    • 8/29/2022
    • TunniqwaLittle

    Bought a Single Family home in 2022 in West babylon, NY.

    Caitlin has been such an amazing agent to me. She literally held my hand through my journey of purchasing my first home. Caitlin knows her stuff!! As soon as we met, she ...
    Caitlin has been such an amazing agent to me. She literally held my hand through my journey of purchasing my first home. Caitlin k...
  • 5.0
    • 3/3/2022
    • zuser20140824063142182

    Sold a Condo home in 2022 in Central islip, NY.

    Caitlin was a pleasure to work with. She provided much knowledge to the interested buyers and was very pleasant and professional every step of the way. I was super please...
    Caitlin was a pleasure to work with. She provided much knowledge to the interested buyers and was very pleasant and professional e...
    5.0
    • 5/4/2021
    • JenniferCatSuarez

    Bought a Single Family home in 2021 in Farmingville, NY.

    If I can give Caitlin 100,000,000 stars I would. Working with her has been a wonderful experience especially since this was our first home purchase. She set us up with an...
    If I can give Caitlin 100,000,000 stars I would. Working with her has been a wonderful experience especially since this was our fi...
  • 5.0
    • 5/4/2021
    • agoncalves412

    Sold a Single Family home in 2021 in Farmingville, NY.

    Caitlin was very professional and responsive during the selling of my house, and will look for her expertise once I purchase my new house in the near future, definitely w...
    Caitlin was very professional and responsive during the selling of my house, and will look for her expertise once I purchase my ne...
    5.0
    • 1/14/2021
    • remi1476

    Bought and sold a Single Family home in 2020 in East islip, NY.

    Great experience! Caitlin is well informed in the few houses she showed us and it didn't take long to find our dream house. Personable and knowledgeable is a great combo ...
    Great experience! Caitlin is well informed in the few houses she showed us and it didn't take long to find our dream house. Person...
Skip to the beginning of the carousel
Add a review

Caitlin Shelton

Realty Connect USA
2sales last 12 months
58total sales
$525K-$785Kprice range
$641Kaverage price
20years of experience